DUX COMPUTER DIGEST

 

Site Search

Site Info

Home » Forums » Forum Archives » Motherboards, Chipsets, Processors, & Memory » Topic # 495

Processor Meltdown
lbyard Sep-18-01 05:14 PM
Tom’s Hardware has tested four processors to see how they stand-up to a heatsink-fan failure. Pentium III and 4 processors survived. Athlon (Thunderbird core) and AthlonMP processors “melted-down” in a ‘fraction of a second.’ I should point-out that the heat sink was totally removed in the tests. The AMD processors with the Palomino core (e.g, Athlon 4 and AthlonMP) do have a thermal protection feature. The AthlonMP may have survived if the heatsink was left in place and the fan cord was pulled instead? That scenario should have been tested. The likelihood of the heat sink I use (http://duxcw.com/digest/Howto/cpu/socka/2.html) coming loose is very low. The tests do show, however, that AMD’s thermal design is clearly inferior to Intel’s and needs immediate attention. The very high temperatures that were measured and the possibilities of a fire hazard and motherboard damage are worrisome. The article with pictures is at: http://www.tomshardware.com/cpu/01q3/010917/index.html. Larry

1. RE: Processor Meltdown
lbyard Oct-30-01 10:26 PM
In response to message 0
Here's an update... http://www.tomshardware.com/column/01q4/011029/index.html.

In a nutshell, motherboards that properly support the Athlon Palomino core processors with the internal thermal diode should protect the processor from burning-up by shutting-down the system. That won’t protect data that hasn’t been saved. Boards that implement this feature are not yet available. I.e., all boards currently claiming Athlon XP compatibility may be compatible, but they do not fully support the processor. Most, if not all, of these boards have a thermister in the center of the socket A That should protect the processor in all cases where the fan fails, probably will not protect them in the extreme case where the heat sink is removed form the processor.

In the mean time, I've had many heatsinks come entirely loose from the socket when shipping a new computer via UPS. What happens if the customer doesn't hear it bouncing around in the case and turns-on the computer? Smoke!

I will have to call the customer and have them remove a side of the case and verify that the heatsink is OK. Not a good situation. Intel's solution appears to be superior. Larry



| Home | Guides | How to | Reviews | Online Store | FAQ | Forums | Forum Archives |
| Links | News | Newsletter | About Dux | Advertising | Contact Info | Privacy |